The Crossroads of Life: Why Every Choice Matters
There is one constant pressing concern shadowing our every moment: choice. For Martin Heidegger, life is a thrownness; for Jean-Paul Sartre, life was anxiety; and for Aristotle, it was the interplay of potentialities into actualities.
For each one of them, choice plays a central role in their understanding of life.
Life seems to be an ever-present series of crossroads, moments diverging along different paths, often with no clear indication of where it will lead.
Whether we treat one of the most iconic poems of America as an ironic play on this freedom in life or as a somewhat straightforward exploration of following your own path, of following your bliss, The Road Not Taken remains a powerful meditation on the almost ever-present demands of choice on us.
Robert Frost’s Hidden Message: Are We Misreading ‘The Road Not Taken’?
I’ve found that people often read America’s favorite poet in a straightforward way, thinking the nice old poet from New England simply depicted rural life.
To me, this is such a major misreading of him, and I think it is chiefly seen in this poem.
They assume that he isn’t trying to play any tricks on the reader, but as any good piece of literature or art shows, there is always a multiplicity of meanings, layers upon layers, or as Pound would say, ply over ply, where one reading contracts and expands into another.
Robert Frost was and remains many people’s first encounters with poetry, and yet he is a Modernist through and through; we cannot get away from this fact.
His poetry as a whole is remarkable in its poetic composition with its colloquial language. He certainly isn’t a favorite of mine, but every encounter with his poetry leaves me refreshed in its complexity.
The Illusion of Reversibility: Why You Can Never Truly Go Back
In the poem, the speaker stands at the junction of two roads splitting into a yellow wood, reflecting on not only the decision itself of which road he should take but on the realities that one choice will cut off the other.
He stands at an either/or choice, trying to discern which is the better choice, as one precludes the other—“way leads on to way”—knowing that the choice itself is irrevocable; it cannot be undone.
He is to be propelled forward, knowing that new opportunities and actualities will open and arise, and yet from that very fact, the other doors and possibilities will close. In the very act of choice, the world itself—or perhaps our experience of the world itself—shifts as a result.
Frost’s line, “way leads on to way,” encapsulates the inevitability of forward motion in life.
We are thrust into this arrow of time, which can only move onward.
Each decision sets into motion a chain of events that cannot be undone.
For a thinker like Sartre, this is a paralyzing proposition.
The absolute freedom in choice and the cascading consequences of those decisions can produce anxiety and despair, which can cause us to flee from authenticity, hiding away in bad faith.
But for Frost’s speaker, this isn’t the conquering recognition of freedom—it is the simple acknowledgment that this reality of which path to take will exclude the exploration of the other.
He doubts that he will ever arrive at this crossroads again to take the other path. The reminder that every decision matters is a very sobering thought; it compels us to accept that despite what we may be able to see as a consequence of a choice, no decision grants us full control over the future.
Related Posts:
The Emotional Burden of Choice: Regret, Responsibility, and Moving Forward
In our own lives, the irrevocability of choices often manifests in subtle but powerful ways.
The university major we select shapes our career trajectory; the relationships we nurture or neglect influence the contours of our personal lives; the opportunities we seize or forgo determine the doors that remain open or closed.
While some choices may seem reversible on the surface, their consequences often ripple outward in ways that make a true return to the starting point impossible.
One of the ways we tend to deal with the immensity of potential in choice is by believing in the illusion of reversibility.
We often have a sense that we will be able to retrace our steps and go back as if we would be able to undo our choice.
We live under the delusion that we have an endless supply of options and flexibility—that if one choice doesn’t work out, we will be able to explore another.
And yet we tell ourselves this in avoidance of the full weight of responsibility. If a particular choice doesn’t pan out, we ourselves are the ones to blame because we are the ones who made the choice.
Frost’s poem reminds us that life’s pathways are interconnected, standing at crossroads with each other, and yet every choice alters the path forward where future decisions will be made.
Even if we were somehow able to get back to the original choice, so much will be shifted and altered that it will almost be as if we were making a new choice, not returning to something we have previously.
Mastering Your Decisions: How to Make Choices Without Fear or Doubt
Consider a professional decision like changing your career.
Maybe you decide to leave the field you have called home for the last few years and try to start your own business.
Many people will tell you, and you yourself might even believe, that if everything doesn’t work out, you’ll be able to go back to your prior career.
But there is always an “opportunity cost”; the experience gained and relationships developed in the interim you left mean that the context of the career has shifted irreversibly.
Or take our personal relationships.
The choice of investing time in one particular relationship or connection over another shapes and molds our emotional landscapes in ways that simply cannot be undone.
Choosing to follow the “exciting” partner rather than the “healthy” partner has led many to the therapist’s couch.
The irrevocability of choice is not about some sort of finality of any particular decision but about the deep and lasting impact of each decision on the trajectory of our lives.
If this strikes a chord in you—the hunger to sharpen, to evolve—explore Poetics of Self-Mastery. It’s for those done with distraction, ready to confront the quiet disciplines that forge identity. No hacks. No hype. Just the art of becoming who you were meant to be.
Read Poetics of Self-Mastery (Why You’re Still Stuck)
Embracing the Path You Took: Finding Meaning in the Choices You’ve Made
Because choice carries with it a permanence, there is often a complex emotional burden running alongside it.
With each choice, much is gained and much is lost, and we all have at times looked at our past with regret over a choice we have made.
We can fall into reflection over the paths we did not take and often get caught up in romanticizing the potential, imagining that they might have led to greater success or fulfillment.
Because we know where the choice has led, we often view the alternative in an idealized light.
And yet Frost’s poem suggests that regret is not something to be suppressed or avoided but that it is an inherent part of the human experience.
Regret comes not because of a perceived failure but because we live in a world of limited choices.
In order to free ourselves from this, we need to fully lean into realizing that the choice we’ve made “has made all the difference.”
There has to be a level of forgiveness and grace with oneself for the past and the roads we did not take and a full embrace of the road we did take.
We cannot go back; the past is the past.
We can only learn from it and embrace its lessons on the road we are currently on.
The choices you’ve made have made all the difference. Nothing has been a mistake or accident, and you haven’t chosen wrongly.
Wake up and become conscious of the road you’ve taken.
Think deeply on the choices to come.
Ready to burn your default thinking? Download Dangerous by Design. Discover the 10 books that fracture, interrupt, and rewire the creative mind. Get the guide & read dangerously.
Pingback: The Illusion of Time: Why Presence in Burnt Norton Eludes Us - Samuel Gilpin
Pingback: The Illusion of What Might Have Been: Letting Go in Burnt Norton - Samuel Gilpin
Pingback: The Silent Killer of Success: How Small Choices Destroy Your Future - Samuel Gilpin
Pingback: The Existential Abyss: Why Uncertainty is the Ultimate Test of Power - Samuel Gilpin
Pingback: The Ruthless Truth About Self-Mastery: Why You’re Still Stuck - Samuel Gilpin
Pingback: After Apple-Picking and The Crushing Weight of Fulfillment - Samuel Gilpin
Pingback: Fractured Genius: Why John Berryman Will Break You Open - Dr. Samuel Gilpin